Pal Joey Review

The Roundabout Theater Company Broadway Production Begins Previews

Nov 18, 2008 M.L. Costa

The scoundrel, the socialite, the sweet girl-next-door, and some showgirls hit Studio 54 with a new Broadway production of this showbiz story set in sinful 1930s Chicago

Joey Evans is a 1930s small-bit nightclub entertainer who, after being booted from a string of other cities, alights on Chicago as the next location in which to spin his schemes and realize his dreams. In his seemingly usual opportunistic and amoral manner, he proceeds to seduce the "mom and apple pie" small town girl Linda English, only to be somewhat seduced himself by her wholesomeness, until he recognizes a way to wangle a free-meal ticket from the sumptuous socialite Vera Simpson.

Broadway Background to Being Back on Broadway

The Roundabout Theater Company has returned to Broadway this Richard Rogers and Lorenz Hart musical, which, due to its use of both glitz and grit, is sometimesconsidered to be a landmark in American Musical Theater. Based on the episodic exploits of the fictional character created in the writings of John O’Hara, who also wrote the book of the original Broadway musical, this production, like many of the revivals of the show, has revised sections of the story and score, and, in some ways, seems to aim, perhaps unintentionally, at combining the tones of the original 1940 Broadway musical with its later 1957 film version, which starred Frank Sinatra, Kim Novak, and Rita Hayworth. Because of this unsuccessfully mixed cocktail, the tone of this show seems to be at odds with itself.

Pal Joey Preview

The first act is slowly laborious in some regards, while other parts of the act are successfully entertaining. By complete comparison, the second act possesses pace and exuberance, and while through the first act the actors seem to have been instructed to control their energy, the performers are permitted to show the full force of their considerable abilities during the much more enthralling second act.

An attempt to artistically alter the mood of the musical from its original patter and purpose seems to have stripped it of its both jovial and movingly honest voice. Uncharacteristically of a production from The Roundabout Theater Company, instead of enhancing the show, at the moment, this production seems to flicker with only glimmers of its potential glow.

Although the show is tag-lined as "beguiled again," Pal Joey will be no Broadway-goer's "pal" unless during these previews the production is tightened and refined to actually beguile again and bewitch audiences.

The Cast

The talented cast seems to be short-changed by a lackluster version of the Rogers & Hart musical, which fails to convey important information and which does not succeed in staging the story and songs either poignantly or amusingly.

Christian Hoff (Joey), Stockard Channing (Vera), Jenny Fellner (Linda), and Martha Plimpton, as Gladys, a both comical and serious singer who provides the audience with some insights about Joey’s past and personality, all contribute much needed "zip" to the show, which cannot be carried by only its popular tunes, “Bewitched” and “I Could Write a Book.”

Theater and Production Information

Previews began on November 14, 2008 at Studio 54, with opening night set for December 11, 2008, but on February 15, 2009, the limited run will close as seemingly quickly as the show’s title character seems to skip town.

The copyright of the article Pal Joey Review in Musical Theatre is owned by M.L. Costa. Permission to republish Pal Joey Review in print or online must be granted by the author in writing.
What do you think about this article?

NOTE: Because you are not a Suite101 member, your comment will be moderated before it is viewable.
post your comment
What is 10+8?

Comments

Nov 24, 2008 8:12 AM
Guest :
Just saw the show yesterday afternoon - no glitz, or glamor here at all. My daughter and I were both "bothered" AND "bewildered" by the loose, wandering, "community theater" feel to the show. None of the numbers were showstoppers, nothing stood out, we didn't even leave the theater humming any of the tunes. The understudy "Joey" stood in and he just was very off the mark, and almost annoying to watch at times. Thank GOD for Stockard Channing and Martha Plimpton - and their characters to brighten up an otherwise very dull and BORING show! DON'T WASTE YOUR MONEY!
Dec 12, 2008 9:09 PM
Guest :
I can't agree more with the other review posted on the 24th. I saw the show tonight and unfortunately, things haven't gotten any better. On several occasions, you could almost see Stockard Channing saying to herself "please let this song end soon so this scene and show will be over." That said, she is definitely one of the shining lights in the production. Another surprise was the girl who played Linda English. She's got some talent. I hate to say it, but I would save my money and spend it elsewhere. In this economy, keep the cash in the bank (or buy the cheapest seats to Wicked and go see that again).
Dec 17, 2008 6:13 PM
Guest :
FWIW, on this the night before OPENING NIGHT, it should be noted that "Joey" now is portrayed by Christian Hoff's understudy. Today's (12/17) NYTimes all but says that Mr. Hoff was unequal to the task. Having seen "Passing Strange" less than a month ago, I think it's safe to say that different shows make different audience members gag (that was my wife and me being SOOO very grateful that there was an intermission where we could cut our losses), I simply have to believe that except for the obscene ticket prices - all the more so given Roundabout's tax-emempt-ness - Pal Joey (even in an uninspired production) is a kind of must-see!
Dec 17, 2008 8:44 PM
Guest :
My husband and I enjoyed tonight's performance. I was very surprised with Martha Plimpton's talents as a song and dance actor.... bravo. I believe everyone at tonight's performance enjoyed themselves to by the round of applause.
Dec 19, 2008 4:06 PM
Guest :
My husband and I saw the show last night. We found out the night before Christian Huff injured his foot and would not be continuing with the show. Our primary reason for wanting to see the show was Christian Huff. Although disappointed, we figured how bad could it be. After about 20 minutes, we both agreed, "pretty bad". I think the actors did well with what they had to work with. But on a whole, the show dragged and seemed to go on for ever. By the last act, the cold night air was looking pretty good.
Dec 19, 2008 5:10 PM
Guest :
Robert Clohessy again puts on a unforgetable performance..
6 Comments